2391 Limberlost Road, Lake of Bays, ON P1H 2J6
Lake of Bays
First time offered in over 30 years on desirable Dotty Lake! This is where memories are quietly layered, year after year. Nestled on approx 1.6 acres with a sweeping shoreline, the park like setting embraces the lake, creating a natural stretch of waterfront that feels entirely your own. A shallow, sandy entry invites long summer afternoons at the water's edge where little ones build sand castles, while deeper water off the dock is where cannon balls and laughter carry across the lake. A game of bocce is on the lawn, wet towels hang over the deck railing, flip flops pile up by the door. You've lost all track of time...and that's the point. This 4 season address invites you back in time to what cottaging used to feel like. Inside, it carries that same easy rhythm. A stone fireplace anchors the living room, while large windows keep the lake in purview. The Muskoka Room quickly becomes the heart of your days. With four bedrooms and a den, there's flexibility for you, your family and friends. The second level offers an independent space where extended family or guests can settle in comfortably on their own. A detached garage and workshop sit just beyond, ready to store your boat, lakeside gear and winter toys. Set on a year-round municipal road, access remains simple no matter the season. Dotty Lake is known for its calm, Algonquin-like setting - where nature feels untouched and the pace stays unhurried. Nearby, Limberlost Forest and Wildlife Reserve offers endless hiking, while snowmobile trails connect you to winter's magical season right from your doorstep. And when you're ready for an ice cream treat, new Muskoka Bear Wear cozies or a dinner reservation, you're just 25 min to Downtown Huntsville. Places like this tend to stay in the same hands for decades. And this one has. Held and cared for over three decades, it's ready for its next chapter.
Estimate only - excludes property tax, condo fees, utilities and home insurance. Rates vary by lender and term; based on semi-annual compounding.
Walkability, transit, and bike-friendliness for 2391 Limberlost Road, Lake of Bays, ON P1H 2J6
Provided by Walk Score®. Walk Score, Transit Score, and Bike Score are trademarks of Walk Score.
MLS# X12955512
Listed by Peryle Keye Real Estate Brokerage
On market since Apr 3, 2026






What comparable homes actually sold for in the last 12 months.






2391 Limberlost Road, Lake of Bays, ON P1H 2J6 is listed for $1,240,000 CAD.
2391 Limberlost Road, Lake of Bays, ON P1H 2J6 has 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms.
2391 Limberlost Road, Lake of Bays, ON P1H 2J6 is a Detached.
2391 Limberlost Road, Lake of Bays, ON P1H 2J6 is in Lake of Bays, Ontario.
2391 Limberlost Road, Lake of Bays, ON P1H 2J6 is currently for sale.
Contact Michael Mezheritsky at +1 (416) 716-4439 to arrange a private showing of 2391 Limberlost Road, Lake of Bays, ON P1H 2J6 (MLS# X12955512). You can also send a message through the contact form on this site.